Muslim Women Who Become Homeless Have Limited Options

By Jackie Spinner
Washington Post Staff Writer
Saturday, December 29, 2007; B01

They sleep in mosques. Or on the streets. Or in Christian-oriented shelters that might hold prayer meetings or services at odds with their own religious beliefs. For Muslim women without a place to live, particularly those who have been battered or are immigrants, being homeless can test their faith at the time they need it most.

When Muslim women are sent to shelters that serve the general population, they are often exposed to lifestyles that challenge their faith, such as drinking, abusing drugs, eating pork and undressing or bathing in front of others, says Imam Faizul Khan of the Islamic Society of Washington in Silver Spring. They return from such shelters “with sad stories,” he says.

The Virginia Muslim Political Action Committee estimates that several hundred Muslim women are homeless in the Washington region, based on U.S.
Census Bureau data and local surveys. That is a small fraction of the homeless population and of the estimated 250,000 Muslims in the region, but local Islamic leaders say the problem has grown in recent years. Kahn said homelessness in the Muslim community was almost unheard of several years ago.

Some Islamic leaders have begun to raise money to establish more shelters that cater to the Islamic community. There are now just two serving the Washington-Baltimore area, according to local mosque leaders. The leaders said they were unaware of any in Northern Virginia.

A four-bedroom, one-bath shelter in downtown Baltimore, the al-Mumtahinah home, holds 12 women. When the brick rowhouse is full, shelter director Nadia Auxila McIntosh squeezes women into a sitting room or dining room. The Islamic Center of Maryland runs another shelter in Gaithersburg, with room for six to eight.

Social workers, clerics and lawyers who work with Muslim homeless women said most were driven from home by abusive husbands or are unable to work because of their immigration status, leaving them without money for housing. Some face both troubles.

“If a battered Muslim woman is also an immigrant, she may be that much closer to homelessness,” said Mazna Hussain, an attorney with the nonprofit Tahirih Justice Center, a women’s advocacy group in Falls Church. “If she doesn’t have the right to work, she can’t build up a safety net.”

A woman who identified herself as Fatem, using the nickname her mother called her as a child in Mali, came to Tahirih for help after she fled an abusive husband in the area. She is now seeking an immigration status that would allow her to work without relying on her husband’s income. She entered the country legally in 2002, but her husband refused to help her apply for permanent residency.

Fatem, who declined to give her full name for fear of retribution from her husband, said she has been staying with her daughter at a townhouse in Virginia that shelters homeless women of different faiths. The people who run the shelter are tolerant of her Muslim faith, Fatem said, but it is difficult to be homeless, to have nothing, to lose the respect of her family.

“I lost everything,” said Fatem, who has two children from a previous marriage in Mali whom she has not seen in almost eight years. “I don’t have anything no more. I feel really shamed for my family living in just a shelter.”

But Fatem said she feared for her life if she stayed with her husband, a social worker.

“He made me hungry,” she said. “He was sleeping with his ex-wife and made her pregnant. Every little money I make I had to give to him. He beat me. He pushed me to fall down. My daughter cried. She think I’m going to die.”

Imam Hassan Amin of Masjid Us Salaam in downtown Baltimore said more Muslim women are seeking shelter. “I’ve been dealing with women who would come to us and don’t have any place to stay. . . . It’s a big issue.”

If the women end up at Christian-oriented shelters, they are asked to “come out of their Muslim dress,” Amin said. “There are almost always prayer circles, and they play gospel music. Muslim women . . . are pushed to be a part of that group.”

Michael Stoops, acting executive director of the D.C.-based National Coalition for the Homeless, said the Washington region has about 12,000 homeless people on any given night. There are more than 740,000 nationwide, according to 2005 data from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.

Stoops said most shelters are privately run. The largest shelter organization is Catholic Charities, he said, followed by the Salvation Army and the Association of Gospel Rescue Missions. Traditionally, Stoops said, many Christian-oriented shelters — he called Catholic Charities an exception — have offered clients “soup, soap, sleep and salvation.”

Stoops added: “I’ve always found that to be offensive. Shelters in this country need to get with this century.”

Phil Rydman, spokesman for the Kansas-based Association of Gospel Rescue Missions, said policies on attending worship services vary within the association’s network. “It is generally not required,” he said.

Steve Morris, commander of the Washington area Salvation Army, said the Christian charity imposes no worship requirement on people it shelters.
“Each of our housing programs in D.C. offer opportunities for worship, but it is clearly at the discretion of the client,” Morris said. “We have a chapel on site and hold regular services there, but clients are free to choose to attend.”

Most women staying at al-Mumtahinah in Baltimore were dressed in scarves and long robes. Some covered their faces almost completely. McIntosh opened the shelter, whose Arabic name means “to be examined,” in March with help from Muslim donors.

In 2003 and 2004, McIntosh was homeless herself in Texas after she lost her job. She said she was assured when she sought shelter from the Salvation Army that she would not have to attend church services, which she would have considered a sin against her Islamic faith.

But the first night she was there, McIntosh recalled, the woman who had given the assurance ordered her to go to Christian worship or pack her bags.
“I left,” McIntosh said.

Based on her experience, McIntosh decided to open the shelter when she moved to Baltimore. She said she was stunned by the extent of the problem. “A lot of sisters are sleeping at the mosques,” she said.

Kenyatta El Sa’id Farag was one. A Muslim convert, she makes $25 every Friday cleaning bathrooms at a nearby mosque. That is not enough to support her and her 12-year-old daughter.

“I know I’m going to have hard times and easy times,” said El Sa’id Farag.
“I have a roof over my head.”

She squabbles frequently with McIntosh, who is trying to encourage her to get a better-paying job instead of waiting for someone to come rescue her from homelessness.

“I know good and well I’m not going on welfare,” said the mother, while mopping up syrup with a waffle in the shelter kitchen.

Out of earshot, McIntosh explained why she has been encouraging El Sa’id Farag to look for more work.

“This is not a free thing,” she said. “I have to pay for it. If you’re not using the space to help better yourself, I can’t help you.”

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/12/28/AR2007122802493.html

No Tags

1 Comment »

  1. Asma said,

    June 5, 2008 @ 3:12 am

    Domestic Violence
    A Societal Imperfection With No Place In A Perfect Religion
    By Asma Hanif
    Muslim Link Contributing Writer

    Peace is the absence of violence. In order to make peace with others,
    one must first have peace within themselves.

    Domestic violence is an affliction disruptive to the peaceful
    co-existence of husband and wife. Such disruptive states infringe not
    only on the immediate family, but also the Islamic family community at
    large.

    Domestic violence does exist within the Muslim community. One may
    consider this existence an imperfection within a perfect way of life,
    or a paradox in which imperfect humans behave imperfectly. However it
    is viewed, it’s presence cannot be denied.

    Dr. Pamela Heath, Medical Director of Muslimat Al-Nisaa, states
    “Domestic violence within the Muslim community is difficult to
    quantify due to under-reporting. It would not surprise me if
    non-Muslim physicians over-estimate it and Muslim physicians
    under-estimate it. Neither is doing any good for the victims or the
    image of Islam”.

    We cannot hope to attain a peaceful existence until we acknowledge
    both on an individual level and at a community level that abusive
    behavior does exist within Muslim individuals and within the Muslim
    communities.

    Admittedly the world is full of problems, ranging from homelessness
    and domestic violence, to drug addiction and fornication.

    If we fail to acknowledge these real world problems, then we allow
    them to carry over into our Islamic way of life, and subsequently fail
    to circumvent the human imperfections which created them.

    However, domestic violence cannot be justified under the guise of
    human imperfection — a cornucopia of experiences, mistakes and
    illusions relative to man’s reliance on his own unguided opinions and
    desires. Therefore, regulation of actions cannot be by our own
    judgment, but by choosing to be guided by the Quran and the Sunnah of
    Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) without any consideration of
    one’s self.

    Communities which fail to discourage violence and persecution in
    accordance with the Quran and Sunnah will also fail to provide
    shelter and social services for its victims. In these communities,
    open harassment, or other harmful acts against innocent individuals
    not only continue unopposed, but they flourish.

    Within the conceptual framework of Islam, a perfect religion, there
    can be no tolerance of domestic violence. Such tolerance signifies a
    passive acceptance of domestic violence as well as an injustice which
    one is unwilling to prevent. Failure to be proactive in the face of
    domestic violence can be understood as a magnanimous indulgence shown
    toward the perpetrator without the moral determination to externally
    disapprove of the action.

    This kind of tolerance implies indifference towards right and wrong
    and in principle, a countenancing of this imperfection.

    Hence, it is clear that tolerance of domestic violence is a failure of
    every man to recognize their religious, moral and ethical obligations.
    Truly, “Man’s inhumanity to man makes countless thousands mourn!”
    Robert Burns.

    Intolerance of domestic violence should be a prominent characteristic
    of believers, nationally and internationally . Further, for the safety
    and protection of those victimized by their and our silence, including
    the ‘covering of faults’, perhaps there should be the establishment of
    some degree of universal recognition of abusers.

    Allah (Subhanahu w taala) Says: “This day, I have perfected your
    religion for you, completed My Favour upon you, and have chosen for
    you Islam as your religion” (Quran, Surah V:3)

    Allah (Subhanahu w taala) completed His favor on us with a ‘perfect’
    way of life, if there are any imperfections in creation, it is due to
    disobedience to Allah (SWT). Even though there exist many examples of
    imperfections in society, none exist as flaws in Islam. When we
    utilize the Quran and Sunnah as our criteria it serves to purify
    mankind from all imperfections.

    Inherent within this perfect religion are ayaat and hadith which
    should touch the hearts and conscience of the ummah compelling them to
    leave behind apathetic behaviors and move aggressively toward the
    elimination of domestic violence as a social ill within the Muslim
    community.

    If we don’t have the desire to make things better, then things will
    never get better.

    Domestic violence has to be resolved in the context of Islam. Those
    who know Islam, understand Islam, and love Islam must become proactive
    in keeping ‘peace’ within this perfect religion.

    The paradigm of thought cannot simply be the abhorrence of domestic
    violence, but must also include the enforcement of the tenets of
    justice contained within Islam, a Perfect way of life. Protecting
    victims should be a simple matter of adherence to the Quran and
    Sunnah. However, preventing abuse requires active work by the
    community at many levels.

    Insha Allah on August 2nd & 3rd, in the Washington, DC area, Muslimat
    Al-Nisaa organization will provide a conference, forum and fundraising
    banquet whereby community beliefs and attitudes that support domestic
    violence will be changed and the entire Muslim community will see
    themselves as part of the solution. SAVE THE DATE!
    GOAL:
    The organization is currently seeking funding for the Dr Maryam Funches Shelter for Muslim Women Victims of Domestic Violence.
    Donate to
    Muslimat Al-Nisaa at www.mnisaa.org or
    Mail: 5115 Liberty Heights Ave,
    Baltimore, MD 21207
    (410) 466-8686

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment